Toby Carvery Edinburgh West by Innkeeper's Collection

Good value, comfortable Hotel

Pros: The room was clean and well maintained, the whole hotel was excellent. The staff were friendly and helpful. Lovely stay, out of the City itself but only a very convenient bus ride into the centre .

Cons: Part of the Toby chain so food choice at the hotel itself is limited. Obviously knew this on booking, but it wasn't an issue as we ate out most nights. Breakfasts were the same I hadn't pre booked and paid for them on the morning as I wanted them. This would be my main gripe as the food would spend a lot of time under very hot lights and so be overdone and dried out especially if not many people were having breakfast. But as I say I knew on booking it was a Toby and still very good value. So only a minor gripe really. Only other minor complaint was the shower cubicle seemed extremely small, possibly better to do away with the cubicle itself and turn the whole bathroom into a wet room.

Nice rooms with awesome breakfast

Pros: Convenient location Excellent all you can eat breakfast Comfortable room

Cons: Staff could be more friendly and inviting

Pros: Stayed two nights in a single room overlooking the main road which was not a problem due to the triple glazing. I could not fault the Toby Hotel Carstorphin 😊 Great value.Realy genuinely nice and helpful staff. Breakfast was very good for ££7.99 👍 I will definitely stay again with my partner next time.

An overnight stay on route to Shetland. It was perfect for a stopover.

Pros: The location is easy to find. Checking in was easy with friendly staff. A huge car park and great bar and restaurant. The room was large and well fitted. A perfect location for one night if going on another journey. The main street had places to eat and drink. I did not take meals and decided to eat out instead. A big comfortable bed with large shower/toilet room.

Cons: Nothing to say it was all good.

Pros: Around 25 mins walk from the zoo bus stop out too most places Room good size Shower good bathroom good size Was family room 212 Plenty of plugs

Cons: Sofa bed mattress old and my niece next day back is hurting Not alot of space to put stuff away ie no drawers large open space wardrobe Couldn't get WiFi if over far side of the bedroom Breakfast food a bit of a let down To much out to dry out and become hard once on the plate

I liked the hotel

Pros: The place was next to the bus station and it was clean

Cons: I had some worries about my check in time and I called and wrote messages, but didn’t have an answer, I received a call back the day after

Pros: Room was great. Breakfast was good value and place was clean. Location was good in relation to Murrayfield.

Cons: The stairs were a health risk as a step is broken and someone used parcel tape to fix it. Cost for the room was steep for what we got.

Great place to stay with everything you need right on the doorstep

Pros: Location was ideal and very clean room with comfy bed. Staff were very helpful with any enquiries you had.

Great location for Edinburgh sightseeing

Pros: Stayed for 2 nights for the Rugby. Staff were extremely friendly and helpful. Location is perfect for Edinburgh sightseeing. The fact that there is parking is such a bonus. Rooms are spacious with kettle tea and coffee. You also have a hairdryer Breakfast is large with cooked and continental options.

Cons: Found it hard to regulate the heating in the room which was extremely warm The bed was good size but unfortunately not the most comfortable bed or pillows.

Good stay once again

Pros: Stayed here quite a few times. Does what it says on the tin