MacDonald Cabins

Pitlochry superman

Pros: Was very rustic, in a rural setting, close to all amenities. My hubby and kids stayed in the cabins with friends in the others, I stayed din the hotel as I wanted to be somewhere without a shared bathroom. They were extremely short staffed, one man to check in and check out, hold down reception, he was also the bar keep, the waiter, the cook and server!!!! With all that he still went to change a broken heater in our friends cabin, and find them more towels, he was Pitlochry superman. He deserves a damn raise

Cons: No kids area, restraunt didn't feel family orientated.

Pros: the location alone makes it worth it. Set right by a river and surrounded by mountains, the views are spectacular and exactly what we came for. The cabins themselves are charming and comfortable, and there’s a great vibe overall. The on-site restaurant stood out — a unique Scotland × Indian fusion menu that was bold, tasty, and a really nice surprise in a remote setting. Staff were friendly and helpful throughout our stay. I’d recommend this place for the views, the atmosphere, and the overall experience.

Cons: There are two areas that could be much better: • The common kitchen needs improvement — it wasn’t as clean as it should be and felt under-equipped for guests relying on it. • The bathroom setup isn’t ideal. The lack of private bathrooms in the cabins was inconvenient. Options for en-suite bathrooms would make a big difference. If they upgrade the facilities and cleanliness in shared areas, it could easily be a 5-star stay.

Honesty beautiful place have recommended it to others staff were loveky.

Pros: The view is stunning and the cabins feel like a magical place

Cons: Toilets were slightly further on which was a bit scary to go over when the middle of the night, the Bothy bar was cold but I think they had an issue with the delivery of wood for the fire

Great night

Pros: Staff very accommodating. Value for money price is reasonable.

Cons: Not that I didn't like but expect a blast from the past. Like early late 80s early 90s with some modernisation. It's luxurious for walkers going the West Highland way.

What a stay

Pros: Be going to macdonald cabins for years now , even when u could camp , its an amazing place full of nice staff well worth a visit

Cons: That I had to go home 😄

Pros: Great place , great location staff was the best as will do anything to help you

Cons: Nothing as it was my 5 th year in a row staying between campsite , pods and even in the hotel

Pros: Friendly staff, great location right on the loch, lodge was lovely!

Comfortable night in cabin

Pros: It was value for money. The heater in the cabin really got it warm and comfortable, and the shower in the shower unit may have been a bit compact but it was one of the best shower I have been in during my trips, there was plenty of hot water and it was powerful 👌

Cons: The lack of WiFi in the cabin was the only downside I came across.

Pros: The place was very nice. Cabin was very good apart from a garment under the bed. Staff were present and helpful.

Cons: The third night some guests were noisy during the quiet period into the early hours. In the morning the kitchen was a mess

Pros: Good price. Cabin surprisingly warm enough despite cold weather.

Cons: New shower block did have nice hot showers, but shower curtains too short so water pooling in the area outside cubicles. No soap. Cooking facilities need vast improvement, lacking some basic kitchen hardware, no choping board, only 1 pot, 1 frying pan, 1 plate, 1 knife, no stirring or cooking spatulas. Taps broken. Electric hob on same worktop as sink a safety hazard. I could go on. Also should mention didnt enjoy the mattresses with heavy duty plastic cover.